Townrs Defender in Review – A Love/Hate Relationship

townrs-defender-1

Tower Defense is a genre well represented on the iDevice, there’s no denying that. And certainly for many people, including me, their first exposure to this genre was playing on this wonderful mobile platform. At the same time, I’ve played some of the best standard TD games available on this system, so when a new one comes along, I’m always curious what new things it will bring to the table. Townrs Defender takes an interesting twist on  the TD genre, one that ultimately pays off well for the game.

townrs-defender-2

You don’t actually place towers or control their defense of the town in this game. Instead, you play as a warrior tasked with defending the town, alongside the towers which are already in place. There’s a nice amount of customization going on with your character, by allowing you to choose gender, specialization in specific skills and ultimately choices in type of warrior you can play as.

townrs-defender-3

The game starts like most Tower Defense games do, with waves of enemies trying to fight their way into your town. Should they succeed in destroying the gate to your town, it’s game over for you. Your character can run around the map trying to help the towers defeat these enemies, luring them away from towers that are becoming weaker (so long as the tower isn’t destroyed, it will slowly regain stamina). When your own hit points get low, you can seek out the Healing Fountain to regain your strength – but even if your character falls, you will be resurrected automatically after 15 seconds.

townrs-defender-4

On the other hand, for each enemy you kill you get experience, and once that meter is filled you gain a level and can use the point you gain to upgrade a particular skill. These skills include upgrading your primary attack, or gaining different spells (which become available at different levels). Each of these spells uses a different touch gesture on the screen to activate, and they each have a different effect (a conical shaped blast, an area effect, a wave that blows out from your character). Each spell works on a timer, so you have to use them at the right moment so as to ensure you’re doing the most damage. The enemies come in various shapes and sizes, from small soldiers and archers, to magic users, powerful elemental knights and boss creatures. For the most part, they will hone in on your character if you’re anywhere near them, so you can use this to good effect to draw them toward (or away from) some specific tower.

townrs-defender-5

So I’ve said a lot of good things about Townrs Defender – yet my review title also mentions “hate” in this relationship. And it’s true – there are somethings that hold back Townrs, and one really unforgivable issue. So let’s start there – the issue is a complete lack of  the save feature. To win a specific level (there is only one map so far, completing the level would be to survive the requisite amount of waves for the difficultly level chosen) you have to play all the way through – or at least, only pause the game (and not leave the game screen) – anything else and you must start over again. Now, I’ve spoken with the developer, and this flaw is being fixed with a release that will be submitted to Apple for approval in the next few days.

townrs-defender-6

Less important issues include the difficultly level – even on easy this game is hard. Surviving past wave 15 is very challenging, and you can’t rebuild towers that fall so once they’re gone you’re left more and more on your own – even as the enemies get harder and their numbers grow larger. The control is also a little finicky; you point to the spot you want your character to run to, as opposed to clicking in a direction on the screen and running that way. Your character’s resurrection upon death takes just a little too long – almost guaranteeing that one of your towers will fall.

But at the same time, I really love Townrs Defender. I find myself coming back to it just to see if I can make it a little further. I mentioned early on in the review that there are different types of warriors you can play as – but each of these is an unlockable class which you can only play as once you complete the Easy and Medium difficulty levels. So there’s incentive to keep trying – and it’s a nice looking game, with a good premise and the promise of more to come. I’m hopeful that the next update comes quickly and resolves the really big saving issue, but even as is I’d recommend you Grab It.

grab-icon

App Summary
Title:Townrs Defender (v1.0)Developer:Prophetic Sky
Price:$4.99App Size:9.4 MB
  • Nice twist on Tower Defense
  • Good customization options for your character
  • Nice graphics
  • Incentives to keep playing
  • No ability to save your game
  • Difficultly level is high even on Easy

appstoreicon

  • Pingback: OnStories » Blog Archive » A new review

  • qwertyriffic

    Wow!! that game looks sick!! i want it!! lol
    you’re reviews are really good, more people should know about you!! ALOT more people!!

    twitter: qwertyriffic

  • HBB

    i want the promo code for townrs defender please.

  • http://www.spoodles.wordpress.com Spoodles

    I think my husband would love this game!

  • http://www.rustysabre.com/ Eric

    Though the genre is starting to grow on me, I’m not a huge fan of TD games. However, while this may be classified as such I think it looks pretty intriguing. It’s nice to see that you don’t actually control the towers directly, but still need their help in order to be successful. Certainly seems like it would be worth giving a try.

  • Daniel

    Great Review!

  • http://www.gamezoneglobal.com wargamer17

    It seems like a Tower Defense with RTS elements. Neat idea. Would be nice to have the option to save.

  • http://www.slidetotalk.com/ Condawg

    Looks sweet! I love tower defense games, and this really looks like a game that is unique enough to stand out in front of the rest in the genre.

  • Lauren

    Great review! The twist seems like it’ll be worth playing despite my numerous other TD games. Thanks for your insight.

  • Luffydkenshin

    Wow, i am a sucker for tower defense but not so much the “ye olde” fantasy” genre, but this game review definately makes me want to see what they have cooked up! I will definately give it a go

  • Jeremy

    Looks like a well crafted game

  • cjsbug

    As the genre of tower defense games becomes more and more crowded, it interesting to see what devs create to make their game stand out amongst the pack. I’m curious to see whether Townrs brings enough new to the table. From your review I’m inclined to say yes (as long as they truly fix the save issue).

  • http://www.touchmyapps.com/author/tma_jim/ Jim Haley

    I recieved a note from the developer a few days ago, I’m going to copy/paste it here for you guys to see:

    “Thought you might be interested to know that our first update pack is finally about to go live. It’ll have sound for combat, music, and save and resume. Also, many bugfixes and UI improvements. Hopefully it’ll address several of the issues you had with the game in your review!

    We’re holding a sale until the update goes live – only $2.99!”

  • Nova

    Meh… nice but is this rlly twr def?

  • Chiffa

    Cheers guys, not sure if I qualify, but why not give it a shot? Would love to win!

  • zbr

    Looks sweet to have to defend your towers from the alternative perspective of the ground rather than building and fighting with the towers ;] Will probably snag a copy even if I don’t get one of the 3 free codes just because it does look so cool and seems pretty darn exciting/fun ;P

  • p-rod

    Interesting game! Looks to be getting fully-featured with the update…

  • Alison

    Looks like a fun game. Hope to win a code so I can try it out myself!

  • lawjmcafee

    Have had my eye on this game. Am dying to try it out.

  • Nico75

    Wow looks like a really great game that puts an interesting spin on tower defense games. I would love to give it a try

  • Louis

    Congrats to zbr, condawg and nico75 for winning a code for Townrs Defender! Enjoy this fun and unique defense game!

  • http://slidetotalk.com/ Condawg

    Thanks :D
    Can’t wait to play it!

  • http://www.chordica.com Joash Chee

    I look forward to checking it out! Have been collecting many tower defense games. :)

  • http://www.townrsdefender.com Nicholas Elliott

    8/27/2009 – Update Pack 1 Released for Townrs Defender, download it if you already own the game, or buy it from iTunes: http://bit.ly/PurchaseOnline

    Highlights:

    - Sound and Music added! Now you can listen to an epic score whilst surrounded by thunderous battle.
    - Save and Resume! No longer will you lose your game if you want to take a break, or are interrupted. Simply choose resume, and pick up automatically from where you left off!
    - Interface updates! Now you can tap and hold to run in a direction, rather than tapping continuously.
    - Gameplay balance, and many bug fixes. The game is now even more fun!

  • Pingback: Dead Panic in Review – TD is dead and panicking? | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: TriDefense in Review – They’re coming at you from all directions! | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: Hero Defense in Review – Good Luck, You’re Gonna Need It. | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: Space Station: Frontier in Review – Heigh-ho, Heigh-ho, it’s space from work we go! | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: Last Front: Europe in Review – Fighting World War II TD style | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: BioDefense: Zombie Outbreak in Review – Surviving is quite a feat! | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: Navy Patrol: Coastal Defense in Review – Seaman Overboard! | TouchMyApps

  • Pingback: A new review | Prophetic Sky

Next ArticleHow to set an Alphanumeric Passcode for your iPhone/iPod Touch